File Protection Comparison

There are multiple ways to protect WordPress media files with our Prevent Direct Access (PDA) Gold, Password Protect WordPress (PPWP) Pro, Protect WordPress Pages & Posts (PPP), and their extensions, namely:

Here are a comprehensive file protection comparison using 5 popular solutions:

 PDA GoldPDA Gold & AR extensionPDA Gold & PPP GoldPDA Gold & PPWP ProPPWP Pro & SR extension
PROTECTION METHOD
Supported file typesAll file typesAll file typesAll file typesAll file typesAll file types
Protect files under Media library It's more convenient to manage and upload your files under the default Media Library rather than a custom upload
Protect files outside of Media library
Protect all files under a folder
Protect HTML files in WordPress.com
Protect page content
FILE PERMISSION CHECKING
Require users to log in
Redirect to "No Access" page
Protected with a password form
FILE PERMISSION RESTRICTION
Limit access by time or click
Grant access based on IP adresses
Grant access based on referrer URLs
Block file downloads
Apply watermark